The best AI legal assistant for a small firm is the cheapest stack that covers your actual tasks: a 20 dollar general assistant for drafting and summaries, a 49 dollar case law search for authority you can open, and a record or contract tool only when volume justifies it. Paxton at 499 and CoCounsel Legal at 784 bundle more, and cost 10 to 16 times as much.
"AI legal assistant" covers four different products that happen to share a name: a chatbot that drafts, a research tool that finds cases, a document tool that reads files, and an intake bot that talks to prospects. Buying the wrong one is the usual mistake, and the price range is wide enough that it matters. This guide is for the solo or small firm lawyer who has to pick, and it prices each task separately. Every figure was read on the vendor's own page and carries its read date. If you want the definitions first, see what an AI legal assistant actually does.
Best AI legal assistant by task
| Task | Tool that fits | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| First drafts, emails, summaries of text you paste in | Claude Pro or ChatGPT Plus | 20 a month | Published by the vendors |
| Finding case law for a motion, with a real citation | Cases | 49 a month, or 24 billed yearly | Our own published price |
| Case law research with an AI citator | Midpage Professional | 100 a month | Published by Midpage, read 10 September 2026 |
| Checking a draft against your record and citations | Clearbrief Solo | 300 a month per user | Read 3 September 2026, confirm current rate |
| Research, drafting and document analysis in one seat | Paxton | 499 a month, or 2,999 a year | Published by Paxton, read 29 October 2026 |
| Westlaw library plus drafting and review | CoCounsel Legal | 784 a month on a 1-year plan | Thomson Reuters configurator, read 9 October 2026 |
| Enterprise drafting platforms | Harvey, Legora | Not published | No public price page |
Read the table by the left column. The question is not which assistant is best, it is which task is costing you hours this week.
What is the best AI legal assistant?
There is no single best one. For a solo or small firm the best value is a general assistant for drafting plus a case law search for authority, about 69 dollars a month together. Paxton or CoCounsel make sense when you want research and drafting under one login and have the budget for 499 to 784 a month.
Three stacks priced for a year
Here is the arithmetic for one lawyer. It uses the published monthly rates above, so check each vendor before you buy.
| Stack | What it covers | Monthly | Yearly |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starter | General assistant plus Cases | 69 | 828 |
| Checked draft | General assistant, Cases and Clearbrief Solo | 369 | 4,428 |
| One login | Paxton alone | 499 (or 2,999 a year) | 2,999 to 5,988 |
| Westlaw based | CoCounsel Legal alone | 784 | 9,408 |
Two things stand out. The starter stack is under a tenth of the CoCounsel price, and it covers the two jobs most small firms ask an assistant for. And Paxton's annual price of 2,999 is half of twelve monthly payments, so a firm that decides to keep it should buy yearly. For three lawyers the starter stack is 2,484 a year and Paxton on annual plans is 8,997, a gap of about 6,500 that has to be justified by the work Paxton does that the starter stack does not.
Can AI replace a legal assistant?
No. AI drafts, summarizes and searches, but it does not file, calendar, talk to a client with judgment, or take responsibility for an error. A tool shortens the time on each task. The lawyer or staff member still reads the output, and the ABA's Formal Opinion 512 on generative AI ties a lawyer's competence and confidentiality duties to exactly that review.
Where each assistant is weak
General assistants write fluently and cite from memory. A case that sounds right may not exist, so every citation has to be opened. That is why the starter stack pairs one with a case law search: type the facts, read the decisions it returns, and use those citations rather than the chatbot's. Our legal drafting AI pricing page compares what each drafting product costs and checks.
Case law search does not draft and is not a citator. Cases returns real federal and state decisions with citations in plain English. Run the result through your citator for later history before you file. See the best AI for litigation attorneys guide for how the seats compare by job.
Bundled platforms are convenient and expensive. About 400 of CoCounsel's 784 is the Westlaw seat, so if you already pay for Westlaw the add-on logic differs, and our CoCounsel pricing page breaks the tiers out.
Enterprise platforms such as Harvey and Legora publish no price and sell to larger teams. For a firm of one to five lawyers the sales process is rarely worth starting.
A buying checklist that takes ten minutes
Write down the three tasks that cost your firm the most hours last month. Match each to a row in the first table. Price only those rows. Start with month to month plans or a 7 day trial, run one finished matter through each tool and compare the output with what you actually filed. Ask each vendor where client data is stored and whether it is used for training. Then buy the smaller stack and add a tool only when a specific task still takes too long.
If your firm is hiring and wondering whether an assistant tool changes the headcount, the best AI for paralegals guide prices the seats for support staff. Always confirm vendor prices on the vendor's own page, and see the ABA professional responsibility pages for the ethics rules.
When the assistant's draft leans on a case, ask Cases in plain English and read the decisions it returns, with real citations. It is 49 dollars a month, month to month, with no sales call. Use the search box at the top of this page.
Informational research, not legal advice. Always verify the citation before you rely on it.
Search case law in plain English
Ask a legal question the way you would say it out loud and get on-point precedents with plain-English summaries, holdings, and citations you can check. Informational research, not legal advice.